(1793-1815) Fitch, Ebenezer
(1815-1821) Moore, Zephaniah Swift
(1821-1836) Griffin, Edward Dorr
(1836-1872) Hopkins, Mark
(1872-1881) Chadbourne, Dr. Paul Ansel
(1881-1901) Carter, Franklin
(1901-1902) Hewitt, John Haskell (acting)
(1902-1908) Hopkins, Henry
(1908-1934) Garfield, Harry Augustus
(1934-1937) Dennett, Tyler
(1937-1961) Baxter, James Phinney III
(1961-1973) Sawyer, John Edward
(1973-1985) Chandler, John Wesley
(1985-1993) Oakley, Francis Christopher
(1994-1999) Payne, Harry Charles
(1999-2000) Vogt, Carl W.
(2000-2009) Schapiro, Morton Owen
(2009-2010) Wagner, William G. (interim)
(2010-2017) Falk, Adam
Brooks, Belvidere (1888-1918)
Bryant, William Cullen
Carter, Barton
Gifford, Don (1919-2000)
Gladden, Washington
Kellogg, Ebenezer (1789-1846)
Kellogg, James Lawrence (1866-1938)
Makepeace, Charles D.
Mears, Brainerd (1903-1972)
Miller, John William (1895-1978)
Mills, Samuel J. (1783-1818)
Muir, Robert (1898-1997)
Parsons, Eben Burt
Perry, Arthur (1865-1938)
Perry, Arthur Latham (1830-1905)
Perry, Bliss (1860-1954)
Perry, Carroll (1869-1937)
Perry, Grace (1858-1937)
Perry, Lewis (1877-1970)
Perry, Walter (1865-1946)
Pratt, James Bissett (1875-1944)
Reynolds, Marcus Tullius
Sayre, Francis B. (1885-1972)
Schuman, Frederick (1904-1981)
Skinner, William Wood, Jr.
Thompson, Benjamin
Thompson, Frederick Ferris (1836-1899)
Thompson, Mary Clark (1835-1923)
Towne, Herbert (1899-1979)
Van Rensselaer, Stephen, III
Weese, Benjamin
West, Stephen
Weston, Karl Ephraim (1874-1956)
Williams, Ephraim, Jr.
Wilson, John P.